Clicker Training Vs Reward Training
Clicker Training
A
clicker is a conditioned (secondary)
reinforcer, a learned signal that is associated with an
unconditioned reinforcer (unconditioned reinforcer = food play
etc). Initially it is fairly meaningless signal to the dog, but
something that it learns to associate with the arrival of a reward.
Conditioned (secondary)
reinforces are paired with primary reinforcers. After a few
pairings the secondary reinforcer takes on a pleasant association.
The secondary reinforcer is a signal that the primary reinforcer is
on the way.
Why use the Clicker as
a Secondary Reinforcer ?
The sound is unique and stands
out from all other sounds in the environment. It is a new sound, so
it doesn’t have any previous bad associations. The click is rapid
and faster than verbal praise. It marks the behaviour at the spilt
second it happens. The clicker itself is small, easy to carry and
inexpensive.
The clicker rewards the
behaviour at the spilt second it happens, praise maybe to slow and
the dog may have moved on to something else by the time you have
said “good boy”.
The clicker tells the dog the
reward is coming, and that it has made a good attempt at that
behaviour. The dog will try to make you click, and will try hard to
please you. In an experienced dog the click means the game is on.
The clicker gives an ego boost, and animals are reinforced by their
own success in manipulating their environment. They enjoy making
you click and will work hard to train you to do so.
Reward Training
A reward is something, which
happens after an act has occurred, a form of payment for a job well
done. You need to have good timing to be able to get the most out
of this method. If your timing is out you could well be rewarding
something you do not want. In some cases the subject does not
always link the receiving of the reward with the act that earned it,
because a delayed reward becomes an unconnected reward.
Both of the methods above are
kind and fair and I have used both. The clicker allows attention to
detail to a greater degree than the reward only based method. I
found teaching tricks such as the spin relatively easy to do using
just reward. However to teach something like the bow I used a
clicker, and it helped to get the precise movement I wanted more
effectively.
Not all trainees have been
completely at ease with the clicker, holding the lead and a clicker
is just too awkward for some people and difficult to coordinate. My
aim is that trainees enjoy what they are doing so I would not insist
on anyone using a clicker.
I have found that it can become
noisy if everyone uses his or her clicker at once.
From my point of view I like
both methods and would encourage the use of the two, but is very
much up to the individual.
Getting Started with the Clicker
Clicker
training is a new, science-based way of communicating with your pet.
It is easier to learn than standard command based training methods.
You can clicker train any animal, cats, birds, horses and even fish,
so don’t feel restricted to your dog!
Start by playing
the clicker and rewarding your dog for doing simple tricks such as
sit, give a paw etc. Eventually you’ll be able to use it to get rid
of the unwanted behaviours which your dog does. Keep notes of what
your dog does and record his progress as you teach him new things
with the clicker. You’ll be surprised at the progress! Reward
yourself as well as your dog for choosing such a fun, sympathetic
method of training. Here are some simple tips to get you started.
How to use
the Clicker
Push and release
the clicker once to get a two-toned click, reward your dog with a
tasty tit-bit Keep the treats small and remember to cut down on the
dog’s daily ration. Do not move your hand containing the treat until
after you’ve clicked.
When you’ve
repeated stage 1 several times click and do nothing, wait for your
dog to do something before giving the treat. Now show him another
treat and wait, in a few seconds he will repeat the behaviour, now
click and treat. Most dogs will sit at first, as this is an easy
behaviour, which no doubt has been rewarded in the past.
- If you want
to express special enthusiasm increase the amount of treats NOT
the amount of clicks, only ever click once (in and out).
- Keep
training sessions short, three five minute training sessions
will be more effective than one fifteen minute one.
- Fix bad
behaviour by clicking good, for example click a dog for keeping
paws on the floor when he greets you or visitors, ignore him if
he jumps up.
- Break the
behaviour down into simple steps, click and treat voluntary or
accidental movements towards the goal. You may coax or lure the
dog into position but you must not push, pull or force. Don’t
use a verbal cue yet that will come later.
- Shape the
behaviour by raising your criteria as soon as your dog gives you
a good response. If he looks confused drop the criteria a step
to allow him to be successful doing something he already knows.
- When the
dog has learned to do something for clicks he will start showing
you the behaviour spontaneously, he’s trying to get you to
click. Now is the time to start offering a verbal cue. Now only
click the behaviour if it happens either during or after the
cue. Ignore any attempts at the behaviour when the cue isn’t
given.
- Don’t order
the dog around, if he ignores a cue it’s simply that he doesn’t
fully understand what’s wanted of him, drop the criteria then
try again.
- Keep your
clicker with you and click any cute behaviour, this will
increase the likelihood of the dog repeating them again so that
you can put them on cue. You clicking several different
behaviours as they happen won’t confuse your dog.
- If you have
more than one dog, separate them during training sessions and
allow them to take turns.
- If you are
not making progress with a behaviour, it may be that you are
clicking too late, ask someone else to watch you and maybe even
click for you a few times.
- Don’t ever
get cross with the dog, if you are feeling frustrated put the
clicker away and have a cup of tea.
Clicker-training is a wonderful, effective way of
enriching your relationship with your dog.
Clicker Training
Workshops
We offer Clicker training
afternoons or evenings so that you become more proficient in using
your Clicker effectively. Watch this space for events coming
up in the near future. |